CleanTalk vs. Wordfence: A Better Wordfence Alternative?
Have you ever considered a WordPress security service that offers essential features, is affordable, and comes with a top-rated support team? If so, I have a great option for you - CleanTalk Security Plugin (SPBCT). In this post, I will review SPBCT as an alternative to Wordfence. I will compare features, pricing, the setup process, and user feedback, including insights from Reddit. But first, let us take a look at what Wordfence is.
Wordfence is one of the most widely used security plugins for WordPress, offering a firewall, malware scanner, and login protection features. However, when users search for a Wordfence alternative, they often look for a solution that is less resource-intensive and easier to manage. Unlike traditional plugins that run scans on the server, many alternatives rely on cloud-based protection to reduce hosting resources usage and improve website performance. A good Wordfence alternative should still provide strong malware detection, real-time threat intelligence, and protection against brute-force attacks without slowing down the site. Some options also include automatic malware removal and simplified setup, which can be more convenient for non-technical users. Overall, choosing the right Wordfence alternative depends on whether you prioritize performance, automation, or advanced security controls.
Features of two security plugins
Both plugins offer the same core functionality, which is in high demand among website owners,
- IP and Country Firewall,
- Malware scanning and removal,
- Notifications about known vulnerabilities in plugins and themes,
- Login security (2FA and brute-force protection),
- Audit log to monitor activity within the WordPress dashboard.
Security by CleanTalk also provides additional features including,
- Recommendations for secure plugins and themes (PSC)
Our security team audits new releases of the most popular WordPress plugins and themes on a regular basis and certifies safe versions as risk-free and enterprise-ready.
- Filesystem watcher
This feature runs filesystem snapshots on selected period and allows you to control which of your site files has been changed between selected dates. Snapshots are stored for 7 days.
- Top-rated support team
The support team behind CleanTalk is often praised for being responsive, helpful, and willing to work with users until issues are fully resolved, with many reviews noting quick replies and hands-on assistance.
Pricing
Moving on to pricing, this is where the most significant difference appears. Wordfence follows a freemium model, where not all features are included in the free plan, and many are limited to manual execution or delayed updates from the Wordfence cloud. SPBCT uses a free trial model, where all features are available during the trial period and for premium users. Below is a full list of security features and their availability for free and premium users in both services.
| Feature / Function | Wordfence Free | Security by CleanTalk |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Free; Premium starts at $149/year | Starts at $9/year per site; unlimited sites from $27/month |
| Web Application Firewall | Included, with delayed rules in Free plan | Included |
| Malware Scanner | Included, with delayed signatures in Free plan | Included |
| Malware Removal | Manual / paid service | Automatic malware cleanup included in plugin features; expert cleanup available separately |
| Brute Force Protection | Included | Included |
| Two-Factor Authentication | Included | Included |
| Country Blocking | Not included in Free plan | Included |
| IP Blocking | Basic manual blocking | Included |
| Vulnerability Alerts | Included | Included |
| Audit Log | Limited / advanced logging in paid plans | Included, with extended logs in CleanTalk Dashboard |
| Live Traffic Monitoring | Included | Security logs and traffic-related protection |
| Cloud-Based Protection | Mostly server-side | Cloud-assisted protection |
| Support | Free forum support; premium support in paid plans | Support included with service |
The difference in pricing is also substantial. SPBCT plans start at $9/year/site, while Wordfence Premium starts at $149/year/site - more than 10 times higher.
Setup Process Overview
The biggest difference is that SPBCT can be set up locally, without requiring public access to your local or staging site. Wordfence Central, on the other hand, requires your site to be accessible from the internet when adding it to the dashboard. Otherwise, the setup cannot be completed.
In all other aspects, the process is similar. Here is a guide to installing Security by CleanTalk.
Redditors
Let’s take a look at what Reddit users think about alternatives to Wordfence.
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Wordpress/comments/1h5xdrh/what_can_i_replace_wordfence_with_on_around_30/
Here people recommend to use WAF + AV included in a hosting. Cloudflare is another option. - https://www.reddit.com/r/Wordpress/comments/18l4ai0/any_alternatives_to_wordfence/
Fail2Ban, Ninjafirewall (plugin), Bulletproof Security was recommended. - https://www.reddit.com/r/Wordpress/comments/1qx4eg5/wordfence_fail_looking_for_alternative/
Here people recommend WPEngine, Security by CleanTalk.
Final thoughts
In this post, I reviewed Security by CleanTalk (SPBCT) as a Wordfence alternative. SPBCT appears to be a strong option, especially for WordPress users who are looking for a solution that delivers high performance at a lower cost and does not rely on upselling.
Ready to upgrade your WordPress security?
Start a safer, more reliable experience with Security by CleanTalk.